Coal Grove Hornets’ tight end Conor Markins makes a catch during a first quarter scoring drive. The Hornets took an 8-0 lead but lost 41-16 to Lucasville Valley in the Division V Region 19 quarterfinal playoff game Saturday night. (Kent Sanborn of Southern Ohio Sports Photos)

Archived Story

Valley topples Hornets, 41-16

Published 1:44am Monday, November 5, 2012

Josh Morrison


LUCASVILLE — The Lucasville Valley Indians exploded in the third quarter with four touchdowns to break open a 14-8 halftime lead and went on to post a 41-16 win in the Division V, Region 19 regional quarterfinal over the Coal Grove Hornets.

Coal Grove (6-4) got on the board first when Brandon Hogsten capped a 16-play, 66-yard drive with a 5-yard scoring run.

Alex Bare found Isaiah Gunther in the back of the end zone for the two-point conversion to give the Hornets an 8-0 lead with 4:42 remaining in the first quarter.

Late in the first quarter, after forcing a Valley punt, the Hornets looked to put together another long drive. But a Coal Grove fumble gave the ball to the Indians at the Hornets’ 26-yard line.

On the second play of the second quarter, Nate Arnett found the end zone from 19 yards out. The extra point was no good and Coal Grove now led 8-6 with 11:11 to go in the first half.

After both teams traded punts and a Coal Grove turnover on downs, Valley took possession at their own 17. After a 1-yard gain on first down, quarterback Will Howard found Ethan Clark-Holbrook down the sideline for a gain of 34 yards.

Five plays later, Howard found Matt Rawlins from 10 yards out. Howard ran in the two-point conversion to give the Indians a 14-8 halftime lead.

Lucasville Valley (11-0) took the opening possession of the second half and went 51 yards in five plays to score. Howard connected with Nate Arnett from 15 yards out for the touchdown and Brice Romanello added the extra point and it was 21-8 with 9:56 to go in the third.

On the ensuing kickoff, Matt Hodge recovered the onside kick at the Hornets’ 33, and two plays later Howard called his own number from 4 yards out to score. Romanello added the extra-point to make it 28-8 with 9:42 left in the third quarter.

After a Coal Grove turnover on downs, Valley took over at their own 46. However, on the first play, Brandon Hogsten knifed through the offensive line and hit Howard before he could hand the ball off to force a fumble that was recovered by Coal Grove at the Indians’ 37.

But Coal Grove could not take advantage as Conor Markins was tackled a yard short on fourth down to give Valley the ball at their own 29-yard line.

The Indians extended the lead when Howard found Hayden Dunn with a 3-yard touchdown pass. The extra-point was no good and the score was 34-8 with 2:14 to go in the third.

On the third play on the ensuing possession, the ball popped up in the air from the Coal Grove running back and was caught in the air by Isaiah Gunther. However, the ball again popped up and it was caught by Cole Delotell who returned it 28 yards for a touchdown that made it 41-8 at the end of the third quarter.

Midway through the fourth quarter the Indians were threatening again, but the Hornets forced a fumble and took over at their own 5-yard line.

Five plays later, Alex Bare found a crease and raced 72 yards for the touchdown. Estep added the two-point conversion to set the final score of 41-16.

Bare finished with 127 yards on 12 carries with a touchdown and was 7 of 13 passing for 78 yards.

Lucasville Valley will move on in the Division V Region 19 semifinals to take on Bucyrus Wynford.

Coal Grove 8 0 0 8 = 16

Lucasville Valley 0 14 27 0 = 41

First Quarter

CG – Brandon Hogsten 5 run (Gunther pass from Bare) 4:42

Second Quarter

LV – Nate Arnett 19 run (kick failed) 11:11

LV – Matt Rawlins 10 pass from Will Howard (Howard run) :52

Third Quarter

LV – Nate Arnett 15 pass from Will Howard (Brice Romanello kick) 9:56

LV – Will Howard 4 run (Romanello kick) 9:42

LV – Hayden Dunn 3 pass from Howard (kick failed) 2:12

LV – Cole Delotell 28 fumble return (Romanello kick) 1:18

Fourth Quarter

CG – Alex Bare 72 run (Estep run) 4:32

Team Statistics


First downs 12 17

Rushes-yards 45-201 38-239

Passing yards 78 85

Total yards 279 324

Cmp-Att-Int 7-13-0 6-8-0

Penalties-yards 5-50 2-20

Punts-average 2-34.5 2-37.0

Individual Leaders

RUSHING – Coal Grove: Alex Bare 12-127 TD, Kyle Estep 15-34, Brandon Hogsten 9-29 TD, Tanner Murphy 3-9, Isaiah Gunther 6-2; Lucasville Valley: Nate Arnett 10-107 TD, Matt Rawlins 4-50, Will Howard 9-46 TD, Blake Howard 5-17, Brice Jordan 4-13, Jordan Delotell 2-7, Brandon Jordan 2-3, Team 2- minus 4.

PASSING – Coal Grove: Alex Bare 7-13-78; Lucasville Valley: Will Howard 6-8-85 3-TD.

RECEIVING – Coal Grove: Conor Markins 3-35, Isaiah Gunther 3-34, Kyle Estep 1-9; Lucasville Valley: Ethan Clark Holbrook 2-53, Nate Arnett 1-15 TD, Matt Rawlins 1-10 TD, Hayden Dunn 2-7 TD.


The Tribune believes it is possible for people with a variety of points of view to discuss issues in a civil manner and will remove comments that, in our opinion, foster incivility. We want to encourage an open exchange of information and ideas. Responsibility for what is posted or contributed to this site is the sole responsibility of each user. By contributing to this website, you agree not to post any defamatory, abusive, harassing, obscene, sexual, threatening or illegal material, or any other material that infringes on the ability of others to enjoy this site, or that infringes on the rights of others. Any user who feels that a contribution to this website is a violation of these terms of use is encouraged to email, or click the "report comment" link that is on all comments. We reserve the right to remove messages that violate these terms of use and we will make every effort to do so — within a reasonable time frame — if we determine that removal is necessary.

Editor's Picks

Bicentennial committee seeks nonprofit status

As soon as the county’s bicentennial committee gets an OK on becoming a non-profit organization, it will gear up its fundraising campaign to recreate the ... Read more

Fighting for Dawson: LOCO helps boy with SVT, heart defects

At a glance, Dawson Mahaney looks and acts like any 9-month-old child would, his bright blue eyes constantly taking in the world around him. On ... Read more

Finding the money: Boggs wants ideas on how to pay for new jail

Coming up with a specified way to fund building a county jail is the next step in the process, according to jail committee chair Les ... Read more