Archived Story

World must solve Syrian puzzle

Published 9:58am Friday, September 6, 2013

While critics abound, American foreign policy in the Middle East is little more than it can be, but a good deal more than it should be.

In the broader window into Middle East unrest lies the complexity of a world made smaller by the cell phone, where unrest cannot be hidden by oppressive governments and where revolution foments in text messages and Twitter and Facebook accounts.

But revolution remains in most cases little more than a pathway to political chaos, where the righteous anger of oppressed citizens seems only to lead to both the demise of corrupt despots and the void of the kind of political understanding required to successfully govern.

Additionally, the factor of religion in social and political settings, as opposed to secular government, has tended to contribute to the inability to identify choices for leaders best able to serve multiple interests of the population.

The examples of Libya and Egypt point to the outcomes that could be expected should the Syrian rebels depose the Assad regime. In both nations the idea of a liberal democracy finds itself in unbreechable conflict with education, religion, and trust.

It is into this expanding shift from oppression to disorder that the United States has been expected to provide some sense of organizing order in the region and in specific states. While there is no path to control the revolutions of change and no practical means to avoid civilian casualties in the wake of such change, the U.S., as the sole Superpower, is somehow looked to calm the violence and provide the direction to new forms of governing.

But the model of democracy, at least where limited by religious intrusion and educational fracture, has not proven particularly useful in restoring order or reason in the region.

So the role of the U.S. has been, so far at least, its ability to source power where it is deemed appropriate to tilt the scale for an outcome that, at best, remains unclear and dangerous for the people living in revolution.

In Syria there is serious concern that the fall of the Assad regime, if occurring suddenly, might open the country to a degree of chaos that has no path to an end beyond fractured regionalism and religious division.

Therefore, any U.S. military intervention may both provoke unanticipated consequences and offer extremely limited support for the people of Syria who are under horrific attack by their own government.

The arguments for intervention have been that our national interest are at stake and the nations of the world have condemned the use of chemical weapons now killing innocents in Syria.

The national interest argument is more about our commitment to the protection of Israel and our insistence to prevent Iran from acquiring a nuclear weapon than about an imposing threat to our country directly.

The moral argument, that the use of chemical horror is beyond the scope of acceptance, is one that should bear response not only by the U.S. but by the Arab nations and all nations who sign the treaties against the use of such weapons.

Yet those who should commit their own forces stand silently aside waiting for the U.S. to act while condemning the U.S. for acting or for not acting.

As long as the United States accepts the role of advancer of democracy and protector of the moral high ground, our nation will be on call for any crisis that occurs anywhere on the planet.

But is perpetual war really the only path forward?

Perhaps so if you think the military industrial complex makes sense for the nation.

But wars kill innocents more than combatants and our contributions have included arming so many who kill their people and then using our weapons to extend the fighting while more innocents die.

Maybe it is time to seek to have Assad declared a war criminal and to invoke the nations nearer Syria to fight to end the killing of mothers and wives and children.

 

Jim Crawford is a retired educator and political enthusiast living here in the Tri-State.

 

 

 

 

  1. mikehaney

    “CNN cannot independently verify the authenticity of these videos but we’re reporting on them because we have verified the Obama administration is showing them to members of congress as they hope to build a case to support military strikes against the Assad regime.” (CNN, Sept. 7, 2013).

    If CNN cannot independently verify the authenticity of these videos, then why are they showing them?
    Canada free Press

    (Report comment)

  2. mikehaney

    The rebels launched the assault on the ancient Christian village of Maaloula _ which is on a UNESCO list of tentative world heritage sites _ on Wednesday after an al-Nusra fighter blew himself up at a regime checkpoint at the entrance to the mountain village. The village, about 40 miles (60 kilometers) northeast of Damascus, is home to about 2,000 residents, some of whom still speak a version of Aramaic, the ancient language of biblical times believed to have been spoken by Jesus.

    Heavy clashes between President Bashar Assad’s troops and Nusra Front fighters persisted in surrounding mountains Thursday, according to the Observatory, which collects information from a network of anti-regime activists.

    Speaking by phone from a convent in the village, a nun told The Associated Press that the rebels left a mountaintop hotel Thursday after capturing it a day earlier. The nun said the frightened residents expect the Islamic militants to return to the Safir hotel and resume shelling of the community below.

    “It’s their home now,” the nun said. She spoke on condition of anonymity for fear of reprisals.

    Al Qaeda led rebel force groups have also reportedly vowed to continue their attacks on Christians as soon as the United States “liberates” the country from it’s President Bashir al-Assad.

    Yesterday Republican Senator John McCain inserted an amendment into a resolution approving military force in Syria with a goal of shifting the power on the battle field from the Assad regime and to rebel forces.

    (Report comment)

  3. mikehaney

    WASHINGTON—As President Obama continues to push for a plan of limited military intervention in Syria, a new poll of Americans has found that though the nation remains wary over the prospect of becoming involved in another Middle Eastern war, the vast majority of U.S. citizens strongly approve of sending Congress to Syria.

    (Report comment)

  4. mickakers

    Jim Crawford; I found food for thought in your comment “the nations of the world have condemned the use of chemical weapons now killing innocents in Syria.” Therefore, the United Nations are the ones to make the ultimate decision, not the United States alone. We are a member of the United Nations. As far as Israel is concerned, you might want to question the Palestinians about the encroachment of Israel into their territory. I found your comment “As long as the United States accepts the role of advancer of democracy and protector of the moral high ground, our nation will be on call for any crisis that occurs anywhere on the planet.” MORAL HIGH GROUND? You gotta be kidding! We kill thousands of the helpless unborn on a weekly basis without the blink of an eye. We are just as guilty as the Syrian government. The rest of the world realizes this. We are no better or worse than the United Nations, it is high time we accept this reality.

    (Report comment)

  5. mikehaney

    Agree Jim, but it is obvious that there is evil on both sides with the innocent square in the middle.

    (Report comment)

Editor's Picks

DNA group has second meeting

More than 40 people attended the second Death to Negative Attitudes (DNA) meeting on Thursday at the Ro-Na Theater. Many of the same people along ... Read more

Barker selected as Memorial Day Parade honorary grand marshal

The selection committee has chosen Hardy Barker as Honorary Grand Marshal of the Ironton Memorial Day Parade, the oldest continually held Memorial Day Parade in ... Read more

Global Warming?

  Temperatures still climbing despite subzero conditions nationally   Despite a cold snap that seems to be gripping the entire nation, experts like Ohio State ... Read more  | 4 comments