Archived Story

Ironton resident claiming hotel work devaluing property

Published 11:11am Thursday, January 30, 2014

An Ironton resident is claiming developers of the new Holiday Inn Express and Suites are devaluing her property and is asking for construction to halt pending an impact study.

Rosetta Roberts, who lives in the 400 block of South Tenth Street, behind the construction site, appeared in Common Pleas Judge D. Scott Bowling’s courtroom Wednesday for an initial hearing on a complaint she filed against the developers, MPH Hotels of St. Petersburg, Fla., on Dec. 5.

In her complaint, Roberts alleges the developers “did willfully and wantonly cause damage to the plaintiff’s (Roberts’) property value.”

She also says in the complaint that she was led to believe that her view would be “unencumbered to look over the parking area.”

“Now the pouring of footers have outlined the building as such has been purposely and with malice so as to put a three-to-five story building directly across from the plaintiff’s property, thus blocking any visibility from public view.”

Roberts goes on to request the construction of the hotel to stop so an impact study can be conducted to determine the effects the hotel will have on her property.

Kevin Waldo, Ironton attorney representing the defense and who filed a motion to dismiss the case on Jan. 14, said Roberts’ complaint “contains no averment which would illicit a legal response,” and further said the complaint was “very vague and an illusory list of things that don’t have any legal impact.”

Bowling agreed that there were some “procedural defects” in Roberts’ complaint and encouraged her to hire an attorney.

“It’s going to be nearly impossible unless you obtain an attorney,” Bowling said.

Roberts represented herself Wednesday, citing she was unable to obtain an attorney at this point who didn’t have a conflict of interest with the building project. She asked Bowling to continue the case until she could get representation.

Bowling set another hearing at 2 p.m. on Feb. 19.

In other cases:

Shawn Delong, 36, of 264 Private Road 349, Ironton, pleaded guilty to a fourth-degree count of grand theft and a fifth-degree count of receiving stolen property.

Bowling sentenced the man to 12 months in prison.

Gary Stephens, 45, of 461 Township Road 1055, Proctorville, pleaded guilty to four counts of fourth-degree trafficking in drugs (oxycodone).

Bowling sentenced the man to two years in prison, a $1,250 fine and a six-month driver’s license suspension.

Christopher Lovins, 34, of Huntington, W.Va., admitted probation violations and was sentenced to six months in prison.


  1. Poor Richard

    Wants to ‘halt’ the work pending a study? Who is going to pay for the contractor’s ‘work stoppage’ during that period he cannot work? deal with a contract that cannot be fulfilled? or the loss of money from the hotel that cannot open on time? Who will pay the room and board for the out of town construction workers? Construction work is ‘temporary’, it has no ‘long term’ affects on property value unless after it is built there is noise, lights, etc that would affect her property. I don’t know about zoning though, if the city did not follow prescribed zoning but made ‘exceptions’ for the hotel maybe she should look to the city, after all, zoning is for protection of citizens property.

    (Report comment)

  2. Digi

    Well now, that complaint about the hotel is about the silliest one I’ve heard in a while! Before they cleared that mess out she didn’t have a view anyways! Bless her heart, there has to be someone in the county that will explain this to her so she understands they aren’t out to destroy her property. I mean what’s it valued at anyways that she’s so worried about?

    (Report comment)

  3. Ironton Cares

    I can’t believe someone would complain and say this would devalue their property, I believe she has complained about other things before but I am so happy she was told to get an attorney because this is helping Ironton and hopefully we are moving forward. I say move if she isn’t happy with this.

    (Report comment)

Editor's Picks

DNA group has second meeting

More than 40 people attended the second Death to Negative Attitudes (DNA) meeting on Thursday at the Ro-Na Theater. Many of the same people along ... Read more

Barker selected as Memorial Day Parade honorary grand marshal

The selection committee has chosen Hardy Barker as Honorary Grand Marshal of the Ironton Memorial Day Parade, the oldest continually held Memorial Day Parade in ... Read more

Global Warming?

  Temperatures still climbing despite subzero conditions nationally   Despite a cold snap that seems to be gripping the entire nation, experts like Ohio State ... Read more  | 4 comments