No deadline on MLB playoff expansion

Published 1:40 am Friday, March 2, 2012

NEW YORK (AP) — Negotiators for baseball players and owners say there is no set deadline for an agreement to expand the playoffs to 10 teams this season.

The sides have said for weeks a deal is likely. When players and owners signed their agreement for a new labor contract in November, the section covering the postseason established a March 1 goal for deciding whether the playoffs would increase by two teams for 2012 or 2013.

But in recent days both sides said negotiations would continue beyond Thursday if they needed time. The sides spoke on condition of anonymity to The Associated Press because the talks have not been public.

Email newsletter signup

The deal would establish a new one-game, wild-card round in each league between the teams with the best records who are not division winners, meaning a third-place team could win the World Series.

Creating it for 2012 has been complicated because the regular-season schedule was drafted last spring and summer, and the extra game has to be put in place in a manner that doesn’t disrupt the World Series schedule. Further complicating scheduling, the sides reached a consensus that ties for division titles would be broken on the field with a tiebreaker game under the new playoff format, and not by head-to-head record.

If the format had been in place last season, the Atlanta Braves in the NL and the Boston Red Sox in the AL would have captured the extra playoff spot. Instead, each missed the postseason by a single game after epic September collapses.

“I would’ve taken it last year,” Braves manager Fredi Gonzalez quipped Thursday.

Baseball Commissioner Bud Selig said Jan. 27 the expansion for this season was on track.

“I really believe we’ll have the wild card for 2012, this year,” he said. “Clubs really want it. I don’t think I’ve ever seen an issue that the clubs want more than to have the extra wild card this year.

“We’re working on dates right now. That’ll all take place. It looks to me like we’ll have it, because I’ve told everybody we have to have it. It’ll be exciting. One-game playoff, it will start the playoffs in a very exciting manner,” he added.

According to the memorandum of agreement, the commissioner’s office was to give the players’ association a modified postseason schedule by Feb. 1.

“The association shall have 30 days after receiving the modified 2012 postseason schedule from the office of the commissioner to determine whether it will grant its consent,” the agreement states. “Such consent shall not be unreasonably withheld.”

Head-to-head record has been used since 1995 to determine first place if both teams are going to the postseason. But the sides decided with the start of a one-game, winner-take-all wild-card round, the difference between first place and a wild-card berth is too important to decide with a formula and a tiebreaker game would be played.

Detroit Tigers manager Jim Leyland said he’s in favor of the expanded playoff format, although he’s not crazy about it being a 1-game playoff at the start.

“It’s possible that somebody could win a division with 84 wins and some other team could get 97 wins and finish behind a team that won 98 — and play one game,” he said. “So it’s never going to be perfect, but at the end of the day, I’m for whatever the commissioner, and more importantly, whatever the fans want. That’s what I think is the best way to handle our game.”

Braves second baseman Dan Uggla said he would prefer that a wild-card round be best-of-three, rather than a single game.

“I’m not a fan of it,” he said. “I don’t think if two teams are good enough to make the playoffs that it should be decided by one game like that.”

Another Atlanta player, pitcher Tim Hudson, said the wild-card winner will be at a distinct disadvantage going through the rest of the playoffs. Last season, St. Louis passed the Braves for the wild card on the final day and went on to capture the World Series. Hudson said it would’ve been much harder for the Cardinals or the Braves to advance if they had played an extra game first.

“The only good thing about it is one more team (in each league) gets in the playoffs,” he said. “But it totally handicaps the wild-card team. Both teams will probably have to expend their best pitcher to win that game. Plus, it’s another day they have to use their bullpen. Even if you get by that one game, the chances of winning the next round are not very good.”

As part of the labor deal, the Houston Astros will switch to the American League for 2013, creating two 15-team leagues with three divisions each. Players wanted the change to equalize the chances for making the playoffs for every division.

Eight of 30 baseball teams have made the playoffs under the format that began in 1995, a year later than intended because of a strike that wiped out the postseason in ‘94. The postseason included just the league winners from 1903-68, then increased to four teams in 1969.

In the NFL, 12 of 32 teams make the playoffs. In both the NBA and NHL, 16 of 30 teams advance to the postseason.

Gonzalez, who considers himself a traditionalist, is willing to give the proposed new format a chance. At first, he wasn’t a fan of the current wild-card system but now believes it has added excitement to the game.

“That turned out to be a positive thing for baseball and kind of kept the hype going for some of those teams that were still in it in September,” Gonzalez said. “We’ll see how it works.”

———

AP Sports Writer Paul Newberry in Kissimmee, Fla., and Noah Trister in Lakeland, Fla., contributed to this report.